Their opinions are also shaped by their actual exposure to panhandling—the more people are panhandled, the less sympathetic they are toward panhandlers.
This tension between opposing viewpoints will undoubtedly always exist. This guide takes a more neutral stance: without passing judgment on the degree of sympathy owed to panhandlers, it recognizes that police will always be under some pressure to control panhandling, and that there are effective and fair ways to do so. Panhandling and its variants are only one form of disorderly street conduct and street crime about which police are concerned.
Other forms—not directly addressed in this guide—include:. Some of these other forms of disorderly street conduct may also be attributable to panhandlers, but this is not necessarily so. These problems overlap in various ways, and a local analysis of them will be necessary to understand how they do. Understanding the factors that contribute to your panhandling problem will help you frame your own local analysis questions, determine good effectiveness measures, recognize key intervention points, and select appropriate responses.
Panhandling intimidates some people, even causing some to avoid areas where they believe they will be panhandled. Whether panhandling intimidates passersby depends, of course, on how aggressive or menacing the panhandler is, but it also depends on the context in which panhandling occurs. In other words, an act of panhandling in one context might not be intimidating, but the same behavior in a different context might.
Typically, relatively few panhandlers account for most complaints to police about panhandling. Contrary to common belief, panhandlers and homeless people are not necessarily one and the same. Many studies have found that only a small percentage of homeless people panhandle, and only a small percentage of panhandlers are homeless.
See, however, Burke for evidence that a high percentage of the panhandlers in Leicester, England, have been homeless. Most studies conclude that panhandlers make rational economic choices—that is, they look to make money in the most efficient way possible. Some panhandlers will admit to passersby that they want money to buy alcohol hoping candor will win them favor , though few will admit they intend to buy illegal drugs.
Given the frequent hostility they experience, maintaining their composure can be a remarkable psychological feat. Some panhandlers hope that candor will increase donations. Here, a panhandler's donation box reveals that the money will be spent on beer as well as on food. Credit: Kip Kellogg.
Most panhandlers are not interested in regular employment, particularly not minimum-wage labor, which many believe would scarcely be more profitable than panhandling. Some panhandlers buy food with the money they receive, because they dislike the food served in shelters and soup kitchens. In some communities, nearly everyone who routinely uses public places has been panhandled.
Wealthy citizens can more readily avoid public places where panhandling occurs, whether consciously, to avoid the nuisances of the street, or merely because their lifestyles do not expose them to public places. Estimates of the percentage of people who report that they give money to panhandlers range from 10 to 60 percent. Come to find out she was dead.
You can give in so many ways. I will let God be the judge. By Andre Brinson. I am sure people who donate have had some kind of bad feedback from time to time. But keep in mind that many or even most panhandlers either have or have had some type of mental or emotional problems. I have panhandled before and horrible things have been said to me.
And trust me, even selling Street Sense does not mean it is always a good day. I know vendors who cannot handle someone not speaking to them or not buying a paper.
I tell them to focus on doing what they set out to do. So, vendors, remember: be polite; keep an open mind; and, smile. And also remember good overrides evil — every day. By Reginald Black. I am a native Washingtonian, a Street Sense vendor, and an advocate for the homeless. The homeless community needs constant donations. We need, food, clothing, and shelter. But most of all we need housing. How will homeless people earn money if people are told not to donate?
We all are in need of something. We should remember how we have gotten to where we are. There are great disparities in our world. Not lending is one of them. Money is how people obtain housing. They have to survive, and tomorrow is not guaranteed. People should think about giving because we may not meet the next day.
We must have money because it is the only way to obtain housing. So I ask people in Fairfax: What would happen if you did not give to individuals? How will they survive? Will you criminalize them? Will you help them? By Ibn Hipps. My father beat me in the head and other places with a baseball bat and other blunt objects.
He whipped me on my naked back. He made me watch when he beat my mother with extension cords. When I told him, he told me I was a liar.
I was always told I was stupid and would never amount to anything, just like my mother. So I started to believe him after a while. Maybe he was right. Even when they are, though, I understand. It was hard to break the wall down. She has seen him for years. In fact, that spot is so popular, panhandlers show up in Google Maps street view. Other times, families with children approach her in shopping center parking lots and ask for money.
Alyssa asked KUOW her quandary:. Giving money doesn't feel right, but neither does just driving by. Even giving to organizations that help the homeless doesn't do anything for the individual standing in the rain on the other side of my car door right now. What can I do to help them, especially if children are involved? Father Hagelin: Every single person that you come into contact with has a great dignity. It's really important to treat them not as a nuisance, not as an eyesore, but as a child of God; as someone who has immense dignity.
And so if it's a homeless person that you are able to have more than one encounter with, someone that you maybe you see every day. I would say the most important thing is to know their name. Begin a conversation with them, maybe even get to know their story a little bit. Anna Boiko-Weyrauch: Once you go beyond that, how do you know what will actually truly help them?
Father Hagelin: Well hopefully have the opportunity for them to tell you. If you're able to put them in touch with resources that might be able to get them off the street, or in a good direction. Those resources are out there, and so educating yourself to know them. Boiko-Weyrauch: Rabbi, when you hear this how do you respond to it? Does this resonate for you?
How do you answer this question? Rabbi Berkovitz: It resonates a lot. You have to see the humanity in the person. It is easier and easier to just walk past and come up with the justifications for why we're not going to help.
They're going to use the money to buy alcohol, whatever that is. We can't walk by. We can't not act.
0コメント